Casey,
I own one of each; a supercharged V8, 360 Magnum, and a turbocharged slant six (225 motor.)
I like 'em both... pretty much, equally... partially, becauce at the moment, I think a drag race between the two would be very, very, close and might even be a dead-heat, if that is possible. I never intended that; it just turned out that way...
The difference is, the supercharged car (a 1972 Valiant 4-door) is about 600-pounds heavier then the '64 Valiant, turbo-slant. But, its V-8 engine is 60-percent bigger...
The V-8 has a Vortech, V-1, S-trim, centrifugal blower, running a maximum of ten pounds of boost, while the slant 6 is running a 66mm Turbonetics turbocharger currently, with a
waste-gate limited 15 pounds of boost.
They both have 904 transmissions and moderately; higher-than-stock stall speeds.
If I were going to recommend one forced-induction method vs. another, I think a centrifugally-blown slant six with a belt-driven supercharger would be the ideal setup for the street. Ten pounds of boost could be easily attained with either. a Vortech, Paxton, or ProCharger head unit, and it could run on pump gas and no intercooler would be needed. Stock engine internals would work fine, I think.
Steve Nitti has a slant-powered Duster with a belt-driven, ProCharger blowing thru an elactronic fuel injector, and it is pretty fast.... very low 11's, the last I heard. Might be in the tens, by now...
There are reports of turbo-slants that are faster, but not much...
That would be my druthers..... for a near-stock motor.
You pays your money and, you take your choice!
Bill, in Conway, Arkansas